Orders for October, November, and December are now accepted.

845-718-1621

Elegantly Baked by Shenny
  • Home
  • Cake Pricing & Inquiries
  • Cake Flavors
  • Wedding Cakes
    • Wedding Cakes
    • Flavors & Tastings
  • Shop
    • Custom Cake Menu
    • Cookie & Treats
  • Meet the Baker
  • FAQ
  • More
    • Home
    • Cake Pricing & Inquiries
    • Cake Flavors
    • Wedding Cakes
      • Wedding Cakes
      • Flavors & Tastings
    • Shop
      • Custom Cake Menu
      • Cookie & Treats
    • Meet the Baker
    • FAQ
Elegantly Baked by Shenny

845-718-1621


  • Home
  • Cake Pricing & Inquiries
  • Cake Flavors
  • Wedding Cakes
    • Wedding Cakes
    • Flavors & Tastings
  • Shop
    • Custom Cake Menu
    • Cookie & Treats
  • Meet the Baker
  • FAQ

Bite Into Happiness

Luxury Louis Vuitton-themed cake with red roses.
Elegant 50th birthday cake with cigars and whiskey decorations.
Elegant Hermes-themed birthday cake with flowers.

Custom Cake Menu & Pricing

Simple Celebration Cakes

 Single-layer cakes with a clean, simple design, perfect for birthdays and intimate celebrations. 

Price

  starting at $120 

VIEW & ORDER

Our Standard Cake

 Two layers of cake with one layer of filling, perfect for birthdays, smaller celebrations, and everyday sweet moments. 

Price 

Starting at $130

VIEW & ORDER

Tall & Elegant Cakes

 One-Tier Cakes Includes 3 layers of cake and 2 layers of filling. Perfect for smaller events with big style. Custom flavors and designs available 3 layers (≈6½–7” tall) 

Price 

Starting at $150

View and Order

Extra Tall Luxury Cakes

Double-barrel cakes featuring 4–5 layers of cake with 3 layers of filling, designed for extra height, servings, and a stunning presentation. 

Price 

Starting at $180

view & order

Heart Cake

 

Description:
Signature heart-shaped cakes available in 2 or 3 layers, customized with your choice of flavors, colors, designs, and edible images.

Price:
Starting at $140

View & Order

Trendy Sheet Cakes

 

Classic rectangular cakes available in single or double layers. Double-layer cakes include your choice of chocolate or vanilla buttercream filling, with specialty fillings available as an upgrade.

Price:
Starting at $150

View & Order

Birthday Packages

Custom cakes and coordinating treats for your celebration.

Prices shown are starting prices. Final pricing varies based on design, fillings, toppers, and custom details.
Starting at $150

View & Order

2-Tier Custom Cakes

 Two-tier cakes featuring 3 layers of cake and 2 layers of filling per tier. Perfect for weddings, showers, milestone celebrations, and elegant events.

Price:
Starting at $200

View & Order

3-Tier Custom Cakes

 

Elegant three-tier cakes featuring 3 layers of cake and 2 layers of filling per tier. Perfect for weddings, milestone celebrations, and upscale events.

Price:
Starting at $480

View & order
Biscoff 9-inch Bundt cakes are perfect for anyone who loves a rich, flavorful cake

Bundt Cake

Our 9-inch Bundt cakes are perfect for anyone who loves a rich, flavorful cake without a lot of buttercream. Each Bundt cake is made to order and can be customized in a variety of flavors and finishes. Pricing starts at $75 and up, depending on the flavor and any additional toppings or enhancements selected.

View & Order

Reviews

Copyright © 2026 Elegantly Baked by Shenny - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

  • Cake Pricing & Inquiries
  • Wedding Cakes
  • Custom Cake Menu
  • Cookie & Treats
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept