Orders for October, November, and December are now accepted.

845-718-1621

Elegantly Baked by Shenny
  • Home
  • Cake Pricing & Inquiries
  • Cake Flavors
  • Wedding Cakes
    • Wedding Cakes
    • Flavors & Tastings
  • Shop
    • Custom Cake Menu
    • Cookie & Treats
  • Meet the Baker
  • FAQ
  • More
    • Home
    • Cake Pricing & Inquiries
    • Cake Flavors
    • Wedding Cakes
      • Wedding Cakes
      • Flavors & Tastings
    • Shop
      • Custom Cake Menu
      • Cookie & Treats
    • Meet the Baker
    • FAQ
Elegantly Baked by Shenny

845-718-1621


  • Home
  • Cake Pricing & Inquiries
  • Cake Flavors
  • Wedding Cakes
    • Wedding Cakes
    • Flavors & Tastings
  • Shop
    • Custom Cake Menu
    • Cookie & Treats
  • Meet the Baker
  • FAQ

Wedding Cake Tasting

Find Your Perfect Flavor 🤍

Wedding Cake Tasting Box — $75

A curated wedding cake tasting experience featuring 4 signature flavor variations, with 2 slices of each flavor.

Includes:

  • 4 flavor variations
  • 2 slices of each flavor
  • Choice of 1 cake base collection
  • $50 tasting credit applied toward your final wedding cake order when you proceed with booking

Important Tasting Information:
The Wedding Cake Tasting Box is created from one cake base collection only. Choose from Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, or Carrot & Spice. Your box will include four flavor variations from your selected collection.

Cake base collections cannot be mixed within the standard tasting box. Flavor variations are subject to availability and may be curated based on the current tasting menu.


Heart-shaped cake with "Just Married" topper.

Luxury Mini Cake Tasting

The Luxury Tasting Experience ✨

Luxury Mini Cake Tasting — $200

An elevated wedding cake tasting experience featuring 4 individually prepared 4-inch, two-layer mini cakes, allowing you to experience each flavor as a complete mini cake.

Includes:

  • 4 individual mini cakes
  • Each cake is 4 inches and 2 layers
  • Choice of up to 2 cake base collections
  • Choose 2 flavor variations from each selected collection
  • $50 tasting credit applied toward your final wedding cake order when you proceed with booking

Flavor Selection:
Choose up to two cake base collections: Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet, or Carrot & Spice. Select 2 flavor variations from each collection for a total of 4 mini cakes.

A maximum of two cake base collections may be selected for the Luxury Mini Cake Tasting

Wedding Cake Flavor Collections

Discover Your Wedding Cake Flavors ✨

Explore our signature wedding cake flavors and find the combinations that speak to you. Flavor selections are organized by cake base collection to make choosing the perfect tasting experience simple.

Vanilla Collection 🤍

🤍 Vanilla Collection

Vanilla Dream — Classic vanilla cake with a smooth vanilla finish.
Funfetti Celebration — Vanilla cake with colorful celebration sprinkles.
Strawberry Bliss — Vanilla cake paired with strawberry filling.
Strawberry Shortcake Crunch — Vanilla cake layered with strawberry filling and our signature strawberry shortcake crunch.
Cookie Chaos — Vanilla cake paired with cookies & cream.
Biscoff Magic — Vanilla cake paired with rich Biscoff cookie flavor.
Caramel Cake — Vanilla cake paired with rich caramel.
Banana Cream — Vanilla cake with creamy banana-inspired flavor.
Coconut Oasis — Vanilla cake complemented by tropical coconut.
Lemon Love — Vanilla cake brightened with refreshing lemon flavor.
Caramel Apple Pie — Vanilla cake paired with warm spiced apple filling and caramel.
Peach Cobbler — Vanilla cake paired with sweet peach and warm cobbler-inspired flavors.
Champagne Vanilla — Vanilla cake with delicate champagne notes.
Strawberry Champagne — Champagne-inspired vanilla cake paired with strawberry.
Peach Bellini — Champagne-inspired vanilla cake paired with sweet peach.
Coffee-Kissed Vanilla — Vanilla cake complemented by smooth coffee notes.

🍫 Chocolate Collection

Chocolate Fudge — Rich chocolate cake with a decadent chocolate finish.
Chocolate Strawberry — Rich chocolate cake paired with strawberry filling.
Oreo Obsession — Chocolate cake paired with cookies & cream.
Reese’s Dream — Chocolate cake paired with creamy peanut butter flavor.
Turtle Temptations — Chocolate cake paired with caramel and pecan.
Espresso Explosion — Rich chocolate cake complemented by bold espresso notes.
Drunken Love — Rich chocolate cake complemented by smooth Irish cream flavor. ❤️

❤️ Red Velvet Collection

Red Velvet Classic — Rich, velvety red velvet cake with a smooth vanilla finish.
Red Velvet Rum Bliss — Red velvet cake complemented by warm rum-infused notes.
Cookies & Cream Red Velvet — Red velvet cake paired with cookies & cream.
Irish Cream Velvet — Red velvet cake complemented by smooth Irish cream flavor.

🥕 Carrot & Spice Collection

Classic Carrot — Warmly spiced carrot cake with a smooth vanilla finish.
Pineapple Carrot — Spiced carrot cake complemented by sweet pineapple.
Biscoff Spice — Warm spice cake paired with rich Biscoff cookie flavor.
Caramel Spice — Warm spice cake paired with decadent caramel.

🇯🇲 Caribbean Signature

Rum Lovers — A lighter Caribbean-inspired rum cake with warm, aromatic flavors and a rich, smooth finish. Perfect for couples who want a touch of Caribbean tradition without the richness of traditional Jamaican Fruit Cake.

🇯🇲 Traditional Jamaican Fruit Cake

Our Traditional Jamaican Fruit Cake is available as a specialty wedding cake flavor for couples who want an authentic Jamaican tradition as part of their celebration.

Unlike our standard wedding cake flavors, Traditional Jamaican Fruit Cake is sold and priced by the pound rather than by serving size. The size and quantity needed for your wedding will therefore be determined by the desired cake weight and design.

Because this cake requires special advance preparation, couples who know they would like Traditional Jamaican Fruit Cake for their wedding should inquire and reserve their order at least 2–3 months in advance.

Please Note: Traditional Jamaican Fruit Cake is not included in our Signature Cake Slice Tasting or Luxury Mini Cake Tasting. If you would like to sample it before booking, a fruit cake must be purchased separately when available.

Specialty pricing applies.

Order your tasting box

Copyright © 2026 Elegantly Baked by Shenny - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

  • Cake Pricing & Inquiries
  • Wedding Cakes
  • Custom Cake Menu
  • Cookie & Treats
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept